← All research

Evidence review // Resuscitation

Mechanical CPR: What 14 Studies Say About Compression Devices and Smart AEDs

Mechanical CPR matches good manual CPR but does not beat it. Its value is where people cannot keep CPR going: transport, rough terrain, few rescuers.

15 November 20261 min readXOVAI Research

14 papers on mechanical chest compression devices and smart resuscitation technology. Each paper was found at its source and its figures checked against the abstract.

1. Landmark RCTs: mechanical vs manual CPR

  • LINC Trial: JAMA 2014. LUCAS was equivalent to manual CPR (4-hour survival 23.6% vs 23.7%).
  • PARAMEDIC Trial: Lancet 2015. No 30-day survival benefit (6% vs 7%).
  • CIRC Trial: Resuscitation 2014. AutoPulse equivalent to manual CPR (discharge 9.4% vs 11.0%).

2. Device safety and head-to-head comparisons

  • Koster safety trial: Eur Heart J 2017. LUCAS was non-inferior to manual CPR for injury. AutoPulse wasn’t shown to be.
  • Eichhorn pig model: Biomed Res Int 2017. corpuls cpr produced higher blood pressure than LUCAS II.
  • COMPRESS protocol: Scand J Trauma 2021. Protocol only, no results yet.
  • Alpine rescue crossover: Scand J Trauma 2021, Egger et al. corpuls and LUCAS 3 stayed stable over rough terrain.

3. Emergency department and workflow

  • Rolston MTV-CPR: JAHA 2020. ROSC rose from 26% to 41%.
  • Levy deployment QI: Resuscitation 2015. The pause to apply the device fell from 21 s to 7 s.
  • Crowley in-hospital registry: Resuscitation 2024. Mechanical CPR was linked to lower survival in hospital (11.8% vs 16.9%).

4. Smart AEDs and defibrillators

  • de Graaf cprINSIGHT: Resuscitation 2021. Pre-shock pause fell from 22 s to 8 s.
  • Lechleuthner corpuls3 MAX: Resusc Plus 2026. MAX terminated fibrillation more often across all shocks (80% vs 72%).

5. Systematic reviews

  • Cochrane review: 2018. 11 RCTs, 12,944 patients. Devices are equivalent to manual CPR, not superior.
  • CDA-AMC review: 2025. Routine use isn’t recommended, and there’s no cost-effectiveness data.